• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
New City Logo

New City Insurance

Employee Benefits & HR Consulting Firm

  • Benefits Consulting
    • 401k & Retirement
    • Employee Benefits Benchmarking
    • Executive Benefits
    • Group Health Insurance
    • PEOs
    • Wellness Plans
  • HR Compliance & Technology
    • Benefits Administration Technology
    • Employee Benefits Compliance
    • Growth Strategy
    • HR & Payroll Integration
    • HR Support
  • Our Process
  • Request Consultation
  • About
  • Blog
  • Contact
  • Client Portal
  • 888.210.2759
  • Request Consultation

Benefits Benchmarking Strategies That Drive Results

June 23, 2025, by New City Insurance

human resource management networkDid you know that 70% of employees would consider switching jobs for better benefits? Offering a compelling benefits package is necessary to attract and retain top talent in a competitive job market. Benefits benchmarking enables companies to gain the insights they need to evaluate how their offerings compare to industry standards, identify gaps, and make informed decisions.

Let’s review some actionable benchmarking strategies to drive meaningful results and help your company stay ahead in the talent race.

Setting Your Benchmarking Foundation

The first step to effective benefits benchmarking is laying the groundwork for a strategic approach that aligns with your company’s goals and workforce needs. Rather than going straight to the data, it’s essential to establish a clear definition of success, determine which benefits to evaluate, and identify the right peer organizations for comparison. This foundation sets the stage for meaningful insights and informed decisions.

Defining Clear Objectives

A successful benefits benchmarking strategy starts with well-defined objectives. Establishing specific, measurable goals helps show that your efforts are focused and aligned with your business’s broader talent and business strategies.

Are you aiming to improve employee retention, stay competitive in your industry, or control rising benefits costs? Clearly outlining these targets will guide your benchmarking process, help you select the correct data, and facilitate easier evaluation of progress and ROI.

Identifying Important Metrics

Once your goals are in place, the next step is to identify the important benefits data points that will yield the most valuable insights. Focus on metrics that align with your objectives, such as participation rates, cost per employee, plan utilization, and employee satisfaction.

Choosing the right metrics can help secure that your benchmarking efforts are targeted and actionable, providing a clearer picture of how your benefits compare and where adjustments may be needed.

Gathering Meaningful Comparison Data

To gain actionable insights from benchmarking, it’s essential to collect reliable and relevant comparison data. This means going beyond general industry averages and focusing on peer groups that reflect your company’s size, location, and industry.

High-quality comparison data helps confirm that your benchmarking is accurate and applicable to your specific situation by establishing that you’re measuring your benefits program against businesses with similar structures, challenges, and workforce characteristics.

Industry-Specific Benchmarks

CRM for improving customer satisfaction scores

Benchmarking is most effective when it’s personalized to your specific industry. Different sectors have particular benefits, expectations, cost structures, and compliance requirements. Sourcing data from businesses within your sector provides more actionable and accurate insights.

Look for industry reports, association surveys, and sector-specific benchmarking tools to gather relevant data. Analyzing this information can help you better understand your current position and how to develop a benefits package that meets industry standards and employee expectations.

Competitive Analysis Methods

To stay ahead, it’s essential to compare your benefits package not only to peers, but also to market leaders. Utilize techniques such as side-by-side plan comparisons, employee surveys, and third-party benchmarking tools to assess how your offerings compare. Analyzing total rewards, not just individual benefits, provides a clearer picture of competitiveness and highlights opportunities to enhance your program and attract top talent.

Transforming Data into Action

Gathering and analyzing benchmarking data is only helpful if it leads to meaningful change. After identifying gaps and opportunities, you’ll need to turn insights into strategic actions. This involves aligning your findings with business goals, collaborating with partners, and making informed adjustments to your benefits offerings. By creating a clear action plan, you can make sure that your benchmarking efforts translate into tangible improvements with a long-term impact.

Creating Implementation Plans

Turning benchmarking insights into results requires a well-structured implementation plan. Start by prioritizing the most impactful changes based on your goals and available resources. Define precise steps, assign responsibilities, and set timelines to secure accountability.

Whether it’s enhancing existing benefits or introducing new ones, your plan should be realistic, measurable, and aligned with employee needs. A thoughtful approach can make sure that your improvements are both strategic and sustainable over time.

Measuring Success

To elevate the impact of your benchmarking-driven changes, it is essential to establish clear key performance indicators (KPIs). These might include employee satisfaction scores, benefits utilization rates, retention metrics, or cost savings.

Tracking these KPIs over time helps you assess what’s working, identify areas for future improvement, and demonstrate ROI to partners. Ongoing measurement is important to keep your benefits strategy agile, effective, and aligned with both employee needs and business goals.

Elevate Your Benefits Strategy Today

core benefits, work-life balance, wellness programsIn a rapidly evolving job market, using benefits benchmarking is essential for designing a benefits package that effectively attracts, retains, and motivates your workforce. By setting clear objectives, identifying the right metrics, and using meaningful comparison data, your business can make strategic, informed decisions that drive real results.

Are you ready to elevate your benefits strategy and stay ahead of the curve? Contact the professionals at New City Insurance today to learn how our knowledgeable consultants can help transform your benefits program for lasting success.

Have Additional Questions?
Call Today: 888.210.2759
Request a Consultation

Filed Under: Benchmarking

Primary Sidebar

Have A Question?

Ask a question or request a consultation, and we will respond to you in a timely manner.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Footer

New City Logo
Corporate Headquarters 600 B St STE 300, San Diego, CA 92101
888.210.2759
info@newcityinsurance.com

Link to company Facebook page

Link to company Twitter page

Link to company LinkedIn page

Insurance Products

  • Commercial Insurance
  • Pay-As-You-Go Workers Comp
  • Group Health Insurance
  • Workers Comp
  • Self Funding
  • Minimum Essential Coverage

Benefits Consulting

  • 401k & Retirement
  • Employee Benefits Benchmarking
  • Executive Benefits
  • Group Health Insurance
  • PEOs
  • Wellness Plans

HR & Technology

  • Benefits Technology
  • Benefits Compliance
  • Growth Strategy
  • HR & Payroll Integration
  • HR Support

Industries

  • Aerospace
  • Biotech
  • Engineering
  • IT
  • Manufacturing
  • Gas & Oil
Google Rating
5.0
New City Insurance
New City Insurance
5.0
Briar Schwartz
Briar Schwartz
05:38 10 Apr 25
Working with the team at New City Insurance was a great experience, couldn’t recommend it enough. Being completely new to the insurance world, both Clayton and Eric were thoughtful and kind, and most importantly patient with my many questions. All in all 5/5 stars. Thank you New City!
Iris deBruin
Iris deBruin
03:24 10 Apr 25
The team at New City was incredible. Clayton walked me through every step, made everything easy to understand, and was always there when I had questions. I felt supported the whole way through—can’t recommend them enough!
Lea R
Lea R
22:46 09 Apr 25
New City was outstanding from start to finish. Incredibly professional, responsive, and genuinely caring. They made everything easy to understand and completely stress-free. Couldn’t recommend them more!
Brooks Chiongbian
Brooks Chiongbian
21:21 07 Apr 25
I ran into an issue with our carrier and Nick got right to the bottom of things. He and his team were incredibly responsive and helpful, making what could have been a frustrating situation so much easier to handle. They really went above and beyond to make sure everything was resolved quickly and smoothly. I’m super grateful for their support and highly recommend New City Insurance to anyone looking for a team that truly cares about their clients!
Elizabeth Teposte
Elizabeth Teposte
23:35 02 Apr 25
My Experience with New City has been amazing. Team Eric has been great, especially Nicholas Rebis their follow up time is a 10/10. I'm currently helping an employee out with her questions and have been running to Nicholas, before I say bye to our team member, letting her know I will follow up as soon as I hear something, I see his response. Thank you to the team for making it easier for me to assist our employees during difficult times.
Chelsea Antczak
Chelsea Antczak
17:54 02 Apr 25
New City Insurance is an outstanding company that genuinely prioritizes its clients. They are professional, highly knowledgeable, and always delivers the best solutions. I highly recommend them to anyone seeking a trusted insurance advisor who truly has your back.
Stephanie Gillon
Stephanie Gillon
19:16 22 Mar 25
I'm here to tell the world to look no further in your insurance search! Seriously, this company is it. I am beyond impressed with the skill set of this team. They are extremely motivated and dedicated to helping their clients and offer top-tier service. I was treated with such care and professionalism throughout our entire interaction together. Thank you, Eric and team, for being so thorough, kind, and efficient while helping me find the lowest prices possible!
Roshaun LaForce
Roshaun LaForce
23:06 20 Mar 25
New City Insurance has such a great team. They genuinely care about their clients and make the whole process easy!
Alec Remington
Alec Remington
00:54 20 Mar 25
A great team of hard workers. My experience with them has been nothing but positive. Highly recommended.
Morgan Ostrander
Morgan Ostrander
16:00 19 Mar 25
Great team to work with! They lowered our costs and have provided excellent service.
Zach Baker
Zach Baker
15:19 19 Mar 25
Eric and the team at New City Insurance are truly top-notch. It’s clear they genuinely care about their clients and work hard to provide the best service possible. Their integrity and dedication really set them apart. Highly recommend!
Momo Furusho
Momo Furusho
13:24 19 Mar 25
New City is run by not just a competent team, but people who genuinely care about providing the best service possible. Eric Calciano is a gem!
Allie B
Allie B
19:34 04 Feb 25
Excellent service and support from start to finish! The NCI team is professional, responsive and truly cares about their customers.
Deana Hartland
Deana Hartland
16:04 14 Jan 25
These guys are great and definitely go above and beyond. We were overcharged for a surgery that my husband had in Aug 2024 due to the contract that they had with our health insurance. It was very difficult trying to work and deal with trying to get this refund back from the surgical hospital we went to. A lot of playing phone tag with them. My husbands HR team got "Nicholas" involved and OMG.....he just handled everything. He stayed in constant contact with me via email on every step of the way. Eventually he was able to get this money refunded that was $997. He has been on top of it from day one. I must say he took all of the stress off of me dealing with this situation during my working hours and went ABOVE AND BEYOND the call of duty. I am so happy they got involved and relived me from dealing with this and the stress it would've caused me. You will be very blessed working with a company such as this. Keep doing what your doing!
Justin Hoffman
Justin Hoffman
02:52 17 Oct 24
Always quick to respond. This team is up early and late.
Roger
Roger
16:30 30 Aug 24
Eric Calciano, is as sharp and knowledgeable about health benefits and insurance, as anyone I've ever come across. If you need any kind of benefits analysis I highly recommend him and his firm. He is easy to work with and highly professional.
Timothy Burke
Timothy Burke
04:02 30 Aug 24
I don't leave reviews often, but this one is well deserved and overdue. Clayton provided services to my company prior to his move into the insurance world a few years ago. Always being incredibly impressed with his talent and strong communication skills, I decided to switch our insurance broker and give New City a shot. That turned out to be a great move.The first year, Clayton actually jumped on a plane and flew from Oregon to California just to be onsite and administer open enrollment for my 45 employees. Clayton, Eric, Jeff, Brendan, and the entire team have been a pleasure to work with over the years. The communication, response time, and insurance knowledge is second to none in my opinion. A legitimate 10/10. They are great listeners and strive to really understand the needs of their customers.I'm very selective about giving referrals and making recommendations, but New City has never disappointed. If you are reading these reviews to help make your decision on selecting an insurance broker, this team is 100% a solid option. And if you don't believe me, just look at the other reviews.
Megan Ketter
Megan Ketter
19:48 28 Aug 24
Excellent customer service. Brendan and team are professional, timely, and so appreciated when navigating this complicated insurance world. Very thankfully for them! Highly recommended.
Ailene Chow
Ailene Chow
23:15 26 Sep 23
We have been working with New City Insurance since 2019 at the start of our company and has not look back since. They are responsive and proactive when it comes to advise and also market analysis on what's there in the marketplace. Unfortunately insurance benefits costs has been increasing yearly with differences in the percentage of increase . The New City folks reaches out months before the impending increase takes places and help relook into options or recommendations that they see fit. We were a company of 2 to now 7 permanent staff . While we are small , this company still takes care of us well.
Carol Zhang
Carol Zhang
04:29 06 Mar 22
As a rapidly expanding national media organization, the employee benefits strategy and administration that New City has provided us during our growth has been invaluable. They have been proactive about informing us of the different benefit strategies available to us as we grow as well as managing the additional compliance laws and reporting requirements at each stage of our growth.
Claudia Villalobos
Claudia Villalobos
20:14 03 Mar 22
New City Insurance made navigating through all the health insurances super EASY. Their documents are highly informative, professional, and easy to work with. Thank you for making the process of choosing a health plan so simple. You guys are THE BEST!
Philippe Salas
Philippe Salas
17:02 22 Feb 22
I never expected to have a good time talking to an insurance salesman, but let me tell you Brendan was quite the treat. He was very helpful explaining the options and has a wonderful sense of humor. I hope to speak with him every time I call.
Jennifer Polito
Jennifer Polito
17:15 09 Feb 22
Super easy enrollment process. Fast and friendly customer service. If you are looking for an insurance company that is there for you every step of the way I highly recommend New City Insurance.
Rocky Salas
Rocky Salas
23:46 07 Jan 22
So friendly, I hope to speak to him again in all my future insurance needs.
Rocky Salas
Rocky Salas
23:38 07 Jan 22
So friendly and soft spoken. I hope to speak to him again in all my future insurance needs.
Jose Brena
Jose Brena
13:20 06 Jan 22
Eric Calciano has been extremely helpful in finding and selecting the right insurance coverage for our company. With many options out there Eric assisted us on getting a low cost provider saving more than 20% than from our competitors and providing excellent coverage for our employees.
Anastasia Beaverhousen
Anastasia Beaverhousen
17:05 28 Dec 21
Signing up for insurance was quick and easy. Felicity Sundsboe
SFCC
SFCC
22:08 29 Nov 21
Jeff Stoltey and his team provide excellent customer service. Jeff has always provided my company SFCC with straightforward options. I went to a larger insurance company only to RUN BACK to Jeff at New City Insurance. I recommend them to anyone needing insurance without hesitation.
Kevin Luby
Kevin Luby
19:13 22 Oct 21
Quick, easy & informative. We were able to secure quality insurance for our small business on a tight deadline. Thanks for the help New City.
Theresa Ruybol
Theresa Ruybol
19:30 01 Jul 21
Eric was so great with us. He was very patient and kind as we are a newer smaller organization who is growing rapidly. With that said, we had made our inquiry, he had great rapid response and mostly had to wait on me. Any request that we made and/or questions we had, he was great answering and helping us understand. Then when we were ready for all documents and to move forward, Brendan helped with getting that together and the two of them worked their magic on New City's end to notify me of what was needed, assist me in that process and confirming that all was complete and approved for the coverage. I just want to say thank you all again so much, as insurance has always been confusing to me, and you all made that process go a lot smoother.Thank you
Andrea Ordendorff
Andrea Ordendorff
21:06 07 May 21
I've been working with both Clayton and Brendan for well over a year. As the purchase of our dental practice was delayed well over 14 months they both patiently supported me and continued to make themselves available. When we were officially ready to sign up they made the whole process seamless and super easy. This team is highly knowledgeable, professional, supportive, and efficient! I can't thank them enough for everything they've done.
T W
T W
22:32 30 Aug 20
I love New City Insurance. I never had a good experience dealing with insurance brokers until I started working with Brendan. He’s awesome! He is patient with me and takes the time to answer all my questions. I’m very grateful for all his help and hard work!
Mary Jane Deyette
Mary Jane Deyette
00:57 11 May 20
Jeff Stoltey is so awesome...even thru my company had only two employees, he took the time each year to research and find the best plan for us. The only reason I am leaving New City Insurance is because we no longer have any employees. Thank you Jeff
Alma Ortiz
Alma Ortiz
22:25 23 Feb 20
Brendan was awesome! I couldn't figure out how to pick my plan and he returned my call on a weekend to help me. Outstansing service!
jessica kavanagh
jessica kavanagh
19:53 13 Feb 20
Brendan was so helpful I definitely recommend him if you’re in need of good help and getting it done promptly. Thankyou so much again.
Tricia DeYoung
Tricia DeYoung
19:49 13 Feb 20
I was very thankful I inquired about this info. with Brendan. He was very helpful so I understand the benefits available much better now. Thank you Brendan.
B Bayer
B Bayer
17:43 24 Sep 19
NCI handled almost everything from start to finish. Clayton and Brendan made the plans easy to understand and walked me through the application process. They got me my ID numbers before my cards arrived so that I could keep an appointment I had already scheduled. My last broker wouldn't have done that. 5 stars!
Jessica Lehr
Jessica Lehr
03:36 07 Jun 19
Our staff was interested in a health plan, but we didn't know how beneficial a solid employee benefits package would be for our business to expand. We'd lose prospective employees because they had more options for their medical insurance which was sometimes more valuable than more pay. The New City team was amazing and gave us as many affordable options as possible so that everyone had their needs met.
Mike McClay
Mike McClay
19:36 03 May 19
My employer uses New City as their insurance broker, and I'm always amazed when I call in for assistance by how knowledgeable and attentive their staff is with my requests. Their online benefits platform makes selecting insurance plans pretty darn easy. I would highly recommend their services.
Next Reviews Write a review
powered by Google
Privacy Policy | Terms Of Use